Visitor Visa - B2

Date: 18th May 2018

Applicants: husband(44), wife(38), son (18)
Sponsor: wife's sister in US (10+yrs), currently on green card.

To wife:
VO:any other child
- No

VO:where are u going
Sister's place in California

VO:who is sponsoring
- Sister

VO:where is your Brother in law working
- Mentioned the company

To husband:

VO:where are u working
- Manager at YYYY (local garment firm)

VO:how many people under you
- replied

VO:who is the owner of company
- replied

To the Son:

VO: what do you do ?
- Student, just gave class 12th exam.

Back to the wife:

VO: Where are you working?
- replied

VO:salary of wife and husband
- replied

VO:have u visited US in the past
- No

VO:when did your sister last visited.
- Dec 2017

Checks something on the computer. Says do not meet the criteria, hands over 214(b) and says you can apply again.

Any suggestions on what can be improved ?

Thanks